Overdosing on Ahashverosh and Haman – Missing Esthers and Mordechais

View this email in your browser

The Jerusalem Post  26/02/2020

Overdosing on Ahashverosh and Haman – Missing Esthers and Mordechais

It’s sobering to live in a world overdosing on Ahashveroses and Hamans but missing Esthers and Mordechais. Today, Israel and the United States are led by modern Ahashveroses. Drunk on power, Bibi Netanyahu foolishly paralyzes an entire country for a year in his desperate refusal to retire. For years, many of us believed that whatever our disagreements with him, he woke up daily asking “what’s best for Israel and the Jewish people” – today, he just seems to be asking “what’s best for Bibi?”


Drunk on ego, Donald Trump foolishly puts his prejudices ahead of America’s core ideals. And just like Ahashveroses’ ultimate switch to save the Jewish people didn’t undo other mistakes he made, Trump’s pro-Israel policy doesn’t negate the other damage his bullying causes.


Hamans spread like Coronavirus. Palestinian dictators and enablers train children to hate, teenagers to kill, and their people to accept living in misery as the elites live grandly while getting coddled as the worlds’ favorite underdog. We have strongmen galore, from Hezbollah’s bloodthirsty Hassan Nasrallah to Iran’s oppressive Ali Khamenei to Russia’s wily Vladimir Putin to Syria’s murderous Bashar-al-Assad. True, these contemporary Hamans aren’t as menacing as the Hitlers and Stalins or even the Nassers and Arafats. Yet their power is amplified today because we lack the Esthers and Mordechais of yesteryear too.


In Israel, the yearlong electoral stalemate has demoralized most voters – and sullied the Bibi-alternatives. Within the right, you wonder what might finally propel Naftali Bennett or Ayelet Shaked to break the predicted third logjam by working with Blue-and-White — a party including former generals and former colleagues on the right who accept Israel’s security consensus – because people like Boogie Ya’alon, Gabi Ashkenazi, and Benny Gantz helped define it. You also wonder if any of the Likud Munchkins, who have been diminished by their total devotion to their Perpetual Leader, will ever break, or shake up the Likud Bloc.


In the center, the excitement that surrounded the Blue-and-White campaign launch a year ago has faded. “Politics is ugly and the public arena has become poisoned,” Gantz said in his eloquent opening speech, denouncing “today’s self-absorbed leadership.” This election three-peat has clouded his and his allies’ impressive achievement in creating a party from nothing and winning the most votes in September. Any potential “Esthers” in the party lack star billing, while none of the four leaders has wowed voters as a modern Mordechai.


At least the four-headed-Blue-and-Whiters figured out how to unite against the greater threat. In the US, as Elizabeth Warren slashed, Bernie Sanders bellowed, and Michael Bloomberg stumbled, it became clear who won the 9th Democratic Debate in Las Vegas: Donald Trump. It’s always hard when an incumbent president coasts to renomination as candidates in the other party first slug it out. Ronald Reagan chuckled in 1984 as Gary “Where’s the Beef” Hart tagged Walter Mondale as a creature of special interests, just as Barack Obama beamed in 2012, watching the never-ending GOP contest yank moderate Mitt Romney ever rightward.


Still, 2020’s Democratic Civil War feels particularly uncivil and self-destructive. Rather than pulling it together, Trumpophobia seems to be tearing the Party apart. At the debate, few even bothered offering anything lyrical, constructive, redemptive: no Reaganesque “Morning in America,” no Obamaian “Yes We Can,” to motivate and mobilize.


Even worse, the leading candidate – for now – Bernie Sanders is a walking, talking – or hollering – worst case scenario for the Democratic Party – and the Jewish community.


Sanders seems to be channeling Trump’s strategy of motivating an aggressive minority to bully, then outlast, the moderates, the party grownups. The menace from Bernie Bros is not some Russian ploy – and serious enough to infuriate Joe Biden, Elizabeth Warren, Michael Bloomberg and Pete Buttigieg who challenged Sanders at the debate: “ask yourself what it is about your campaign in particular that seems to be motivating this behavior….” Beyond that, pushing the Democratic Party to the far left in an election that hinges on moderate swing states is like steering the Titanic toward the iceberg.


Even before Sanders libeled AIPAC, claiming it offers a “platform … for leaders who express bigotry,” his rise seemed determined to torture pro-Israel Democrats. Choosing between Trump and a senator who has never shown much love for the Jewish state, who cavorts with anti-Semites like Linda Sarsour and Ilhan Omar, and acts like a proud Bash-Israel-Firster, would be nightmarish. It would be like choosing between eating a poisonous falafel ball laced with ham and a poisonous gefilte fish stuffed with hot peppers.


Perhaps, the Berge – the Bernie Surge – will force Democrats to stop ignoring the disturbing fact that after decades as America’s most pro-Israel party, their Party, while still majority pro-Israel, now houses a wing that is sneeringly, obsessively, anti-Israel – and welcomes, even excuses, some anti-Semites too.


I’ve said it before.  In 1991, the leading right-winger William F. Buckley exposed the Jew-hatred behind Pat Buchanan’s isolationism and anti-Zionism, saying it violated Republican values. It’s time for Barack Obama or another leading iconic Democrat to read out the Israel-haters from the Party of Harry Truman and John F. Kennedy, of Daniel Patrick Moynihan and Nancy Pelosi – all passionate pro-Israel liberal Democrats. That’s not a job for a Mordechai or an Esther – although Jewish Democrats must stop covering up the problem. That’s a job for a non-Jewish hero willing to defy Twitterdumb and the bullies inside the Democratic Party – while preserving Democrats’ greater goal – unseating Donald Trump.



Recently designated one of Algemeiner’s J-100, one of the top 100 people “positively influencing Jewish life,” Gil Troy is the author of the newly-released The Zionist Ideas , an update and expansion of Arthur Hertzberg’s classic anthology The Zionist Idea, published by the Jewish Publication Society. A Distinguished Scholar of North American History at McGill University,he is the author of ten books on American History, including The Age of Clinton: America in the 1990s .   



Copyright © 2020 Professor of History, All rights reserved.

Want to change how you receive these emails?

You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list .